|
Riotous Strike On Coney Lines 1911
THE MOTORMEN AND CONDUCTORS OF ALL THE LINES of the Coney
Island & Brooklyn Railroad Company except the De Kalb Avenue
line suddenly went on strike yesterday morning, for an increase
of 2 cents an hour, and violence and rioting marked the rest of
the day.
The trouble began at dawn, when the railroad company
tried to run cars over the Smith Street line, and by
night more than fifty persons, several of them
policemen, had been injured by rocks and other missiles
hurled by the strikers or their sympathizers.
Many arrests were made, each attended by unusual mob
violence, and it was conservatively stated that Brooklyn
has not been the scene of greater disorder since the big
street car strikes of 1895, when four regiments of State
militia had to be called out to preserve order.
The strike went into effect at about 4 A.M. following
two meetings of the strikers in their headquarters.
Ninth Street and Third avenue, in which they discussed
the ultimatum of the company that the demand for more
wages would not be met. At the first meeting, held about
2 A.M., it was said that there was a division of opinion
as to whether a strike should be called, but at 3
o'clock a meeting was held which was more fully
representative of all of the 375 men affected, it was
said, and a strike was voted unanimously.
Brooklyn did not wake up to a realization that there was
a strike on until about 10 A.M., when the newspapers
told of riots along the Smith Street line. The railroad
company seemed surprised also, and was almost totally
unprepared. Negotiations, however, had been going on
since June 29, when, with the ending of the yearly
agreement with the line, the local division of the
Amalgamated Association of Street Railway Workers of the
United States of America demanded the increased pay.
De Kalb Avenue Men Work On
This union is represented on the Smith Street Line,
running from Park Row over the Brooklyn Bridge generally
by way of Smith and Ninth Streets and Coney Island
Avenue to Coney Island, the Franklin Avenue Line,
running from Delancey Street. Manhattan, over the
Williamsburg Bridge, through Franklin Avenue to Park
Circle, where it forms a junction with the Smith Street
Line: and the Hamilton Ferry up Hamilton Avenue and
Ninth Street, connecting with the Smith Street Line at
Smith Street.
The other line of the system, the De Kalb Avenue Line is
not included in the strike. Employees on the line are
members of the Knights of Labor, which organization
signed a yearly agreement with the railroad company on
June 29.
There was practically no service on the Smith Street
line and Hamilton Ferry line all day yesterday. A few
cars were operated on Franklin Avenue in the morning,
but all traffic was suspended with the increase of
violence on the Smith Street line, where the seriousness
of the situation required all the attention of the
officers of the railroad.
Service on the De Kalb Avenue line remained undisturbed,
except that transfers to the Franklin Avenue line were
of no use. Inasmuch as the company usually carries
100,000 to 200,000 persons to Coney Island on Saturdays
over its lines a large amount of additional traffic was
diverted to the Brooklyn Rapid Transit, making
congestion on these lines even more unbearable than
usual. there was little violence at the Coney Island
Terminal of the lines affected by the strike, few cars
having reached there.
The centre of the rioting was along the Smith Street
line, which is regarded as the most important of the
system. In Smith Street there were two policemen to each
block, but aside from an occasional attempt to block
cars by stalling wagons in the tracks, little trouble
was experienced. At Smith and Ninth Streets where one of
the company's car barns is located, however, there was
trouble almost every minute of the day.
Many
Battles At the Bridge
At this point each car which was ordered to try to make
the run to Coney Island, stopped for instructions from
Superintendent of Traffic, Dennis J. Sullivan. Then,
manned by a strike breaking crew and several policemen,
proceeded at a rapid rate up Ninth Street.
The first stumbling block was the drawbridge over the
Gowanus Canal, where many strikers were hidden. There
several riots took place in the early morning hours. As
the Cars approached the striker's headquarters at Third
Avenue and Ninth street, and from the windows strikers
and their
sympathizers kept up a fuselage of stones whenever a car
appeared with little danger of arrest.
Reaching Third avenue, however the strike breakers and
policemen on the cars took their lives in their hands.
From the Yard surrounding the strikers' headquarters and
out of the building itself, as each car approached,
swarmed a thousand or more men and boys, many with
bricks and rocks in their hands. Rocks filled the air as
the cars passed, many persons being hit. Throughout the
day ambulances remained at this corner to take the
injured to the hospital.
Few cars passed the corner, however, and all that did
were partially demolished. There was no attempt on the
part of the company to carry passengers, for no one
wanted to ride after the news of the strike went through
that section of the city. A single car on the Smith
Street line
reached Coney Island.
Early in the morning several thousand persons were in
Ninth Street, and by noon the crowd had swelled to
5,000. With the rush of the Saturday half-holiday crowd
steadily increasing, the crowd at 5 o'clock numbered
more than 10,000. The police were unable to handle them,
and as a consequence much violence went without an
arrest. Attempts To End Strike Fail
During the day every attempt was made to effect an
agreement between the strikers and the company. Patrick
J. Shea, Executive of the car men's organization,
started at 10 A.M. to go to the City Hall to call on
Mayor Gaynor in the hope of inducing him to intercede,
but he reported later that he had been unable to find
Mayor Gaynor or any other city official. President S.W.
Huff of the railroad company, it was said, was in
Virginia, and Supt. Sullivan said that he could not act
in any official capacity without concurrence on the part
of President Huff. There the matter ended, both sides
declaring late in the afternoon that they would await
developments.
Leader Shea, for the strikers, said: "We are out to
stay, and nothing can move us. I have tried everything
to bring about a settlement, but there doesn't seem to
be any one around to settle with. I feel positive that
there will be no change in our attitude, and in any
event nothing can be done until President Huff of the
railroad company returns from his vacation in Virginia."
One riot, in which a woman figured occurred early in the
morning at Second Avenue and Ninth Street. A Smith
street car was heading for the bridge over the canal,
with rioters in pursuit. The woman approached the car
from the rear, pulled the pole from the wire, and fled
into the crowd, leaving the men to pull the conductor
and motorman from the car.
Policemen surrounded the car and a new crew of
strikebreakers was put in charge. When the car reached
Third Avenue the strikers rushed from their headquarters
and dragged E. Dwyer of 844 Sixth Avenue off, beating
him unmercifully. Dwyer, who was a passenger, and knew
nothing about the strike, was taken to the Seney
Hospital.
At 10 A.M. a crowd attacked a car at the same corner,
beating the motorman, Patrick Schwartz, and the
conductor, Thomas Flynn. Both men were taken to the
Seney Hospital. The car stood in front of the strikers'
headquarters for more than an hour. When a new crew
finally arrived to take it back to the barns every
window had been shattered. Crews Flee Their Cars
An attack was made on a car at Ninth street and Fourth
Avenue after it had successfully passed through the
fusillade of bricks at the corner below. James Ryan, the
motorman, and John Like and George Martin, conductors,
were dragged from the car and carried off bodily.
Following that the crews of three other cars deserted at
the same place and the four cars remained there until
late in the afternoon, when strikebreakers, under police
escort, marched from the car barns in a body and took
them in charge. This was the signal for united action by
the strikers and was followed by the greatest disorder
which prevailed during the day.
The leader in this group of strike-breakers was Fred
Brown, who said that he had been a strike-breaker for
years. He asked permission to take charge of the first
car, and it was granted without dissent on the part of
his associates. He started his car down the hill on the
left track instead of the right. When the car reached
the strikers' headquarters at Third avenue, with the
other three cars following close, it was running twenty
miles an hour. He held a lighted cigar in his teeth and
grinned at the strikers as he passed.
A hundred stones were hurled at him, one striking him
behind the right ear, but doing little damage. Brown ran
his car rapidly all the way to the car barns, where he
was complimented by Supt. Sullivan. Later, it was
learned that he had struck a striker at Fulton and Smith
Streets earlier in the day, and that the strikers had
dared him to make another trip in front of their
headquarters. The other cars, each going at full speed,
but with the motormen and the conductors hidden under
the seats also ran the blockade successfully.
Supt. Sullivan had said just before the four stalled
cars reached the car barns that he would make no more
attempts to run cars after he had the four safely stored
in the barns. But when he heard that the cars had been
brought back with only a few windows smashed and without
serious injury to any of the men he ordered the only
remaining stalled car on the smith Street line to be
brought to the barns by the strikebreakers.
Car
Surrounded By The Mob
This car was stalled in the vicinity of Park Circle. Its
fender had been demolished by a boulder rolled into the
street. After this had been adjusted a crow started the
car, and all went well until it reached Fourth Avenue.
In front of St. Thomas Aquinas Roman Catholic Church,
Fourth Avenue and Ninth Street, a large crowd had
collected and stones, some weighing twenty pounds, were
hurled at the car, which was moving at high speed. The
crowd surged into the street following the car and
joining a still larger crowd near Third Avenue. Mounted
police dashed alongside the escaping car and chased the
crowd, but they could not reach those in the yards
behind the fences, who continued to throw the stones.
Directly in front of the strikers' headquarters the car
slowed up for a moment, and a ten-pound rock struck
Policeman William Keyes, who was on the rear platform of
the car, squarely in the head. Keyes sank to the
platform, apparently dead, and a cry went up from the
crowd. Mounted
Patrolman Wolff had seen the stone thrown, and rode
straight into the yard surrounding the headquarters of
the strikers and arrested D. Clark, a striking
conductor, of 237 Bergen Street, Brooklyn. Ed Walsh,
another striking conductor, of 1250 Park Avenue,
interfered with Wolff and was arrested also.
With these two prisoners on their bands, six policemen
held back the crowd howling for the release of the
prisoners until reserves arrived in a patrol wagon. It
was the critical point in the day's rioting, and
thereafter the police took firmer measures to hold the
crowd in check. At 6 o'clock the strikers' headquarters
were entirely emptied of all loiterers by the police.
The news that three strikers arrested earlier in the day had been
sentenced to five days in jail each seemed to have little effect on the
strikers, some of whom demanded that they be arrested whenever they were
jostled or asked to move on by a policeman. The men who received the
jail sentences were James Ryan of 428 Union Avenue, said to be one of
the leaders in the strike; John Manning of 228 Eighth Street and
Cornelius Carter of 225 Tenth Street. They were charged with inciting a
riot at Ninth Street and Third Avenue. Carter tried to wrench a fuse out
of a car.
More Police For Today
On all sides the scarcity of police sent to preserve
order in the strike zone was a matter of comment. Not
until dark and after the street car company had
announced that it would not attempt to run any more cars
until today did the police assemble in sufficient force
to control the great mob that made Ninth Street and
Third Avenue the base of its operations. Plenty of
police to handle any situation that may arise today have
been promised. It was said that instead of the handful
that failed to keep Ninth Street in order yesterday at
least fifty mounted and twice as many foot men will be
on duty after 6 o'clock this morning.
At 9 o'clock last night, three hours after the last car
had run the gantlet of excited men and boys, the crowd
in Ninth Street was apparently just as great as ever.
Boys in gangs of ten or a dozen marched up and down the
street singing, the strikers and their sympathizers
assembled on the corners and speculated on the outcome,
while thousands of idlers walked up and down between
Third and Fifth Avenues, fighting mosquitoes, hoping to
witness, some sort of a scuffle between the strikers and
the police before the night was over.
Several times the cry "a car is coming" went up and
immediately the street became the scene of a howling
crowd. In every instance what the crowd thought was a
street car turned out to be some other kind of a
vehicle. On two occasions the light that was mistaken
for a headlight, was on a patrol wagon. The other times
it was automobiles that fooled them.
Another matter that caused unfavorable criticism of the
police was the fact that many wagons loaded with rocks
intended for paving or concrete purposes were
continually passing through Ninth Street yesterday.
Between 5 and 6 o'clock in the afternoon, during which
hour the company tried to operate several cars, a Times
reporter saw no less than a dozen wagons loaded with
these dangerous cargoes rumble down the street past the
strike headquarters, at Third Avenue. Boys jumped on
these wagons, and when they got off they were not empty
handed, as was proved by the kind of rocks that were
hurled at the cars that swept past the headquarters of
the strikers at intervals during the hour that followed.
No effort whatever was made to make these rock-laden
wagons use some other street. A policeman who deplored
the fact that his comrades on strike duty were so few in
number dubbed these rock carriers "ammunition wagons,"
and the title was not inappropriate.
At the strike headquarters last night the leaders said
that pressure was being brought to bear on the motormen
and conductors of the De Kalb Avenue Line to strike
today. The strike leaders seemed to think they had a
good chance to get the De Kalb Avenue men out, but they
admitted that they were not certain of success and they
won't be much surprised if the De Kalb Avenue men hold
on to their jobs and refuse to go out in sympathy.
Want Electricians To Go Out
Leaders of the strike said they were doing all in their
power to get the electricians and other powerhouse men
to go out in sympathy, but the general impression seemed
to be that there was little chance of these men going
out. Their union is entirely independent of the car
men's and they are said to be satisfied with their
positions.
The big handicap against which the company is working is
said to be the scarcity of available strike breakers.
Last night the number who could be relied upon was said
to be sixty-four, and not all of these were experienced
men. The strikers claimed that at least forty of these
men had
deserted their new jobs, and returned to Manhattan on a
Hamilton Avenue ferryboat. This, in turn, was denied at
the Ninth Street barns of the company.
There was not so much trouble on the Franklin Avenue
line as on the Smith Street, although all of the men on
this line are out. The only real trouble on that line
occurred shortly before 6 o'clock last night, when a
motorman, who had remained loyal to the company, decided
to be loyal no more, and deserted the car within a block
of the Franklin Avenue car barns.
Slow up the car, the motorman turned on full power and
then jumped off, taking the controller handle with him.
The car without a pilot shot ahead like a rocket and
crashed head-on with terrific force into another
Franklin Avenue car. Both were wrecked, and blockade
that lasted nearly an hour resulted.
The wrecked cars were surrounded by a mob of more than
2,000 men and boys, who amused themselves throwing
bricks, rocks, and bottles through the windows.
The men arrested, only two of whom were striking
employees of the company, were charged with disorderly
conduct. They were Frank Smith, 1717 Greene Avenue;
Edward Simms of Snyder Avenue; Alexander Moore, 1197
Flatbush Avenue and Martin J. Hennessey, 789 Franklin
Avenue. Another Franklin Avenue car was rocked at Second
Avenue and Ninth Street. One rock broke a big window in
a corner saloon, but nobody was hurt.
Late last night it was announced that an effort to
restore the Coney Island service over the Smith Street
and Franklin Avenue lines would be made at 6 o'clock
this morning. The police said that there would be plenty
of men on hand to protect the cars. President Huff Returns
President Huff of the railroad company arrived in
Brooklyn late last night, but refused to talk regarding
the strike. Shortly after his arrival, however, the
company made a statement that the three lines affected
by the strike would run a full schedule today, beginning
at 8 A.M., instead of 6 A.M. as given out in a previous
statement. It was also said that enough skilled car men
had been hired to run all of the cars.
To guard against night attacks by the strikers, two
patrolmen were stationed in each block in Ninth Street
from Seventh Avenue to Smith Street and in Hamilton
Avenue from Smith street to the ferry. In Smith Street
there were stationed two men to each block from Ninth
Street to Fourth Place, and one man to each block from
that point to Atlantic Avenue. A strong force guarded
the railroad company's office at De Kalb and Franklin
Avenues, and all of the company's car barns were
surrounded with guards.
The Public Service Commission announced yesterday that
Inspectors had been sent along the lines of the road
affected during the day, and that the commission would
keep informed as to the situation. This is the first
time in the history of the commission that a serious
railroad strike has occurred exclusively within its
jurisdiction. There was a prolonged strike in Yonkers,
but the cars came into New York City only on one line.
The most serious street car strike in the history of
Brooklyn was in January, 1895. All the lines of the
Brooklyn City Railroad Company, now the B.R.T. system,
were affected and 6,000 men were out. The police were
unable to handle the situation and four regiments of
militia were called out. On January 23, John Kearney, a
resident of Hicks Street, who was viewing the riots in
the street from the roof of his house, was shot and
killed. The strike was unsuccessful for the strikers.
The last B.R.T. strike occurred in July, 1899. A large
number of employees refused to go out, however, and the
strike was ended within a week. Dynamite was used in
this strike to blow up empty street cars which the
strikebreakers had left stalled in the streets. This
strike, like that in 1895, was lost by the men.
[End Of Article] |