The recent arrival of the vessel
John Gibson, at the Erie Basin,
with a crew infected with yellow
fever on board, has caused no
little uneasiness in this city.
The question has been repeatedly
asked. How came the authorities
at quarantine to allow the
vessel to reach port without
being first thoroughly examined.
It was this question that a
reporter of the Eagle put to
Health Commissioner Raymond this
morning.
"I do not think," said he, "the
Quarantine authorities are at
all to blame. The vessel stepped
first at the Delaware
Breakwater, where the United
States Marine Hospital Service
is established, and which is
considered the finest service of
its kind in the world. There the
vessel was given a clean bill of
health, and the authorities at
quarantine allowed her to pass."
"Do you think there is any
danger of yellow fever spreading
from the Erie Basin, where the
vessel lay?"
"Not the least. It would have
been otherwise, however, if any
one had gone on board the
vessel, as then he would be
liable to contract the disease,
as did a young man on Classon
Avenue some years ago, but even
then it is a question whether
the disease would spread. It did
not in the case of the young man
I refer to. I gave this whole
subject more careful
consideration in 1878, when I
attended the meetings of the
American Public Health
Association at Richmond, Va., on
the 19th, 20th, 21st and 22nd of
November of that year. I was
especially interested in
ascertaining the views of those
experienced in yellow fever as
to the contagiousness of the
disease. I put this question to
them: "If a patient with yellow
fever is brought North, without
baggage, is stripped and
thoroughly washed and in that
condition taken into New York or
Brooklyn, can he spread the
disease? Can he reproduce in his
body the poison and infect
others?" While most answered
'No,' some of the most competent
relied 'Yes; and from him you
may have an epidemic.' Dr.
Mitchell, of Memphis, told me of
a case where a man, living in
the woods, came to a train of
cars, took a newspaper from a
passenger and returned to his
home. A few days after he
developed yellow fever and it
spread to his family. Whatever
else this epidemic has settled
it has not in my opinion
established on an unalterable
foundation these two important
principles, namely, that yellow
fever is never of local origin,
and that it is never
communicated from the person.
"What are the peculiarities of
yellow fever vessels?"
"Dr. Gibon, Medical Inspector of
the United States Navy,
expressed the following views,
which he said were held by every
naval surgeon in the service so
far as he knew: 1) The yellow
fever ship is always a foul
ship. 2) A clean ship will not
get yellow fever in yellow fever
ports. 3) Yellow fever can be
enclosed and shut in by
battering down the ship's
hatches and feeding and keeping
the crew at all times on deck.
4) Yellow fever may be carried
from an infected ship to one to
ice ward. 5) The infected ship
must be exposed to extreme cold
before she is safe. 6) The
poison of yellow fever is a
living germ. Dr. Turner, of the
navy, mentioned the Susquehanna,
as having had yellow fever on
board, and as being in New York
Harbor out of commission for
three Winters. One month after
she was put in commission the
disease again appeared on board,
notwithstanding the fact that
she had not again been in a
yellow fever port. The starting
point of the yellow fever
epidemic in New Orleans, in
1878, was supposed to be from
the time a purser on the Ship
Emily B. passed quarantine there
and the disease afterward spread
throughout New Orleans, but a
great number of physicians held
to the opinion that yellow fever
was communicable from the
person. It must also be
remembered that the sanitary
condition of the Southern cities
is not as good as here. When I
went South I found in almost
every instance when yellow fever
prevailed there were leading
vaults whose contents soaked
into the soil and found their
way into the well water used for
drinking. Open ditches with
sluggish streams formed the only
sewers into which drained the
surface and slop water, while
decayed wooden pavements
saturated with all kinds of
filth stretched for miles
through the heart of a city
whose people were dying the
hundreds."
"Then you do not think there is
any danger of yellow fever
visiting this city this year?"
"I do not."