The mob like crowd that stood
waiting last night to see the
trio of baby murderers brought
from the Sixth precinct police
station to Coroner Lindsay's
office could not very well be
estimated in numbers. It was
thickest and most compact at
either end of the line, but it
stretched along Bushwick avenue
from Stagg street across Scholes
and Meserole streets to Montrose
avenue and one long block up the
latter avenue to the coroner's
office. It was composed of men,
women and children, mostly
residents of the thickly
populated Sixteenth and
Eighteenth wards. Their talk was
only of the little helpless
victim, its unnatural 17 year
old mother who had wanted the
child disposed of in order that
she might be free to go to
picnics this summer and of the
two young men who complied with
her wishes by strangling the
little one and burying its still
struggling form in a desolate
mud bank.
The multitude of people was
worked up to so high a pitch of
excitement as to hope for a
successful lynching. The police
feared that some attempt of the
kind would be made, and were
prepared for it. When the
prisoners emerged from the
station house, Peter Schultz and
Adam Haas were handcuffed
together and held in the grasp
of Detective Sergeants Campbell
and Lyons, Mary Wertheimer was
in the custody of Patrolman
Hall. Acting Captain Brown
walked with them and surrounding
the group was a detail of twelve
uniformed and armed policemen. A
howl of rage greeted the
prisoners as they appeared on
the street.
They were walked through
Bushwick avenue and Montrose
avenue to the coroner's office,
the angry multitude pressing as
close to the police guard as it
dared and shouting and shrieking
maledictions and threats in both
English and German. "Hang the
fiends!" was yelled again and
again in the ears of the
miserable, trembling trio, and
women took up the cry and fairly
screamed for special and speedy
vengeance on the mother. The
indignation of the mob, however,
spent itself in loud and fierce
execration, but the prisoners
were thoroughly frightened.
"Their faces were white when
they were brought into the
coroner's office and Mary
Wertheimer was sobbing. In a
little while she regained her
air of jaunty composure, but at
intervals during the inquest she
sobbed again, not from any
feeling of horror at the
recollection of her child's
fate, but simply through fear of
personal violence.
Young Schultz, cowed at last,
shrank into the corner of the
office where the detectives had
seated him and shifted nervously
about with a white, scared look
during the entire proceedings of
the inquest. His terror grew
while the relatives of Adam Haas
were testifying, and an Eagle
reporter, who was seated at a
table close beside the
prisoners, heard Schultz mutter,
with an oath, to Haas: "Yes,
that's their game. They're
trying to save you and slaughter
me." Haas was too nervous to say
a word in reply. He was seated
with his back to a window which
opened in the back yard if
Coroner Lindsay's home. Once he
turned, and seeing the peering
faces of the coroner's neighbors
at the window-panes, arose in
evident terror and pulled down
the blind. Two minutes later the
window was softly opened from
the outside, a girl's hand stole
through and the spring blind
went up with a snap that twisted
its lower edge about the roller
near the ceiling, where it
remained, too high for Haas to
again reach. The crowd outside
was heard to cheer the girl.
District Attorney Ridgway
attended the inquest and aided
Coroner Lindsay in conducting
it. The first witness was
Valentine Haas, an older brother
of Adam Haas, the prisoner. He
said that on Tuesday, May 3, the
day after the child's
disappearance, he had moved,
with his parents and the others
of the household, including Mary
Wertheimer and Peter Schultz,
from 56 Morrell street to 14
Bremen street.
"When did you last see the child
alive?" asked the coroner.
"On Monday night of last week,"
was the reply. "It was about
twenty minutes to 12 o'clock. My
mother, my sister Annie, Mary
Wertheimer and I were there;
also, my brother Adam and Peter
Schultz. Mary wrapped a shawl
around the child and Peter
shoved the child under his coat.
The child cried and Peter made a
little fun with it. When he
started to go my brother Adam
said it was so late he guessed
he'd stay home. Then Mary
Wertheimer said to Adam. "Oh, go
on along with him," and Adam
went. Before they went my mother
said that the child should be
nursed. Peter said, "Oh, give it
the nipple from the bottle. That
will keep it quiet." Then they
went out."
"When did they come back?"
"About 20 minutes to 3." "Did
they have the child with them,
then?" "No." "Had anything been
said before about disposing of
the child?"
"That Monday in the day time
Mary said that she had not been
able to get the child in an
institution. Peter Schultz said
he had heard that a needle
pressed through the top of the
head of a very young child would
kill it. I said, "What's the use
of doing that? Put the child in
a basket and leave it in a
doorway." Then they talked about
putting the child that night
with a woman in Central avenue.
When Peter started out that
night he coaxed Adam to go with
him. The next day we moved.
Peter worked half a day that day
and then came home and went out
with Mamie."
"Were you told anything about
the fate of the child?" "Yes; my
brother told me the next day
that Peter Schultz had killed
the child."
To District Attorney Ridgway the
witness said that the child was
a boy three months old and its
mother was Mary Wertheimer, and
she had said that one Al Kraft
was its father. The witness
identified the suspenders found
about the dead child's neck as a
pair which had been worn by
Schultz before the night of
Monday, May 2, but not
afterward.
"Did Schultz tell you," asked
Mr. Ridgway, "that he had killed
the child?"
"No; my brother told me. He said
that Schultz put the child into
the water and when he took it
out it was still alive. Then he
choked it and put it in the
water again. When he took it out
it was still alive. Then he
choked it and put it in the
water again. When he took it out
it gave one squeal, and Schultz
then dug a hole and put the baby
into it."
"Did he say why?" asked Mr.
Ridgway. " He did it because he
wanted to get it out of the
way."
"When my brother told me about
this," continued the witness, "I
said, "You'd better tell the
police about this. It will be
found out sooner or later. You
and Mamie and Pete will have a
growl, and if it comes out then
you'll get in trouble. You'd
better report it now. This was
on Wednesday. Adam said to wait
awhile. That day he said to me:
"You shouldn't look at Mame so
sharp. She'll suspect that I
told you. If she thinks she's
going to be locked up for this
she'll take poison sure." On
Friday I told the police all I
knew about the case."
Mrs. Maria Haas, the mother of
Adam Haas, testified in German,
Lawyer Merkert acting as
interpreter. "Mary Wertheimer,"
she said, in answer to questions
put by the district attorney,
"came to live with me on
Saturday, May 1. She had the
child with her and it was not
known by any name. She said she
wanted to put the child in a
home and I made a top dress for
it while my daughter, Anne, made
a little skirt."
The scanty clothing found
wrapped and twisted about the
child's waist was identified by
Mrs. Haas as having been made by
her. She said that Mary
Wertheimer on Monday May 2 had
taken the child out to get it in
a home, but had failed and had
said that that night Peter
Schultz would take the infant to
a woman at 74 Central avenue who
would care for it.
"Pretty near 12 o'clock," she
continued, "Peter Schultz said,
"Mamie, I must take the child to
that woman.' Mamie wrapped the
child up in a shawl and Peter
put it under his coat. Then
Mamie said he shouldn't harm the
child, and that it might be
better to leave it home, but
Peter said 'No; I promised this
woman.' Then Mamie told my son
Adam to go out and see that the
child was not harmed. Adam went
out with Peter. I saw the dead
child afterward in the station
house and identified it."
Annie Haas, a brown haired girl
of 19, better dressed and
seemingly more intelligent than
any of the others mixed up in
the case, gave similar
testimony, explaining first that
she was the sister of Adam Haas.
She, too, said that Mary
Wertheimer, just before the
child was taken, seemed anxious
for a moment to have it left
with her and then asked Adam
Haas to go with Peter Schultz
and watch the child.
"The next day," continued Annie
Haas, "I said to Mary
Wertheimer, "Mary, where's your
baby.' She said, 'It's up with
that lady in Central avenue.'
Saturday morning my brother
Valentine told me why Adam and
Peter Schultz and Mary were
arrested. I identified the dead
child at the station house, and
saw the nipple from the bottle
still in its mouth. The
suspenders here are the
suspenders which Peter Schultz
wore on Monday of last week."
Detective Sergeant George
Campbell testified to having
arrested the prisoners about
midnight last Friday and of the
conversation he had with them
afterward. "Haas," he continued,
"told me that Schultz,
accompanied by him, took the
child from 56 Morrell street on
the night of Monday, May 2. They
went along Bushwick avenue to
Boerum street and through
Johnson avenue to the south side
railroad. Then they walked along
the track over the new bridge
and across the meadow to the
bank of the pond near the head
of Newtown creek canal. Haas
said that Schultz at first
choked the child. It gave a
squeal and Schultz took off his
suspenders, fastened one end of
them to a stone, the other end
around the child's neck and
threw the child into the pond.
The stone slipped from the
suspenders and the baby floated
to the surface. Then Schultz
waded out after the child, took
it to the shore, gave it another
squeeze about the throat and
buried it.
"After that," continued the
detective sergeant, "Schultz
admitted to me that he choked
the child, but said that while
it was still alive he gave it to
Haas and that Haas also choked
it. We found the body after a
three days' search buried in the
bank of the pond about a foot
and a half under ground. The
suspenders were still fastened
about the child's neck."
Detective sergeant Joseph Lyons
testified that he took Mary
Wertheimer from the jail to the
Sixth precinct police station
and that she identified the body
as that of her child.
Dr. Joseph M. Creamer, who made
the post mortem examination,
said that the child was a boy
about 3 months old. He found a
pair of suspenders tied around
the child's neck, and two
bruises on the scalp as though
the child had been struck,
either before or after death.
The cause of death was
strangulation.
Coroner Lindsay charged the
jury, and, by request of
District Attorney Ridgway,
explained that it was not
necessary to show that Mary
Wertheimer was present at the
death of the child to hold her
as an accessory. This was the
verdict:
We find that the male child
whose body was found near the
head of Newtown creek canal came
to his death by asphyxia at the
hands of Peter Schultz and Adam
Haas, and we believe the mother
of the child, Mary Wertheimer,
to be an accessory to her
child's death.
The prisoners were committed to
await the action of the grand
jury and were escorted back to
the Stagg street station under
the same strong police guard
that had brought them to the
coroner's office and surrounded
by the same howling, hooting,
threatening mob. Several hundred
people waited outside the
station house door after the
prisoners had been returned
there to see their departure for
Raymond street jail. Only a
glimpse of them was caught, for
they were placed in the patrol
wagon and driven through the
stable doorway on a gallop.