Chapter II: The Dutch West
India CompanyNew
Netherland was the name given by
the Dutch whose own country was
called the Netherlands, or Low
Countries to the region about
the river that Hudson had found.
The first official record of
that name is in a trading
license granted by the States
General of Holland a governing
body corresponding in a way with
our Congress to certain Dutch
merchants in the year 1614; and
the name also appears on a queer
old map that was made in the
same year.
After the fur trade fairly was
opened, the affairs of the
little colony that consisted
only of the trading post on our
island and of a few other
trading posts in the back
country were managed for a time
by an association of merchants
known as the New Netherland
Company. Then, on the 3d of
June, in the year 1622, the
great Dutch West India Company
was chartered by the States
General; and among the many
rights granted to that company
were the rights to own, to
govern, and exclusively to trade
with, New Netherland. That was a
very unfortunate arrangement for
the little colony, as the
government that the company,
gave it was bad from first to
last. In order to understand why
that government was bad it is
necessary to know a part of the
company's history.
The West India Company was a
stock company organized by
merchants, but it was created
less to carry on peaceful trade
than to make war against Spain.
For many years the Spaniards had
oppressed cruelly the
inhabitants of the Netherlands,
and the desire in Holland an in
Belgium to fight Spain and to
thrush her was very strong. Mr.
Motley has told the story of
that famous struggle between the
little power and the big power
in his history of "The Rise of
the Dutch Republic," and a
better story of brave fighting
for noble principles never has
been put into words.
In the very year that Hudson
came into our harbor in the half
Moon, the year 1609, the Dutch
had signed with Spain a twelve
years' truce. They wanted time
to pull themselves together,
because most of them meant to go
on with the fighting when the
truce came to an end. But some
of them were willing to submit
to Spanish rule and did not want
to fight'; and between the war
party and the peace party there
was a conflict through all the
time that those early Dutch
ships were coming here for furs.
The conflict ended in the year
1621, when the twelve years'
truce expired; and it ended in
the war party getting its way.
The most persistent worker on
the war side was the founder of
the West India Company, Willem
Usselinex who was one of the
many Belgians driven by Spanish
persecution to take refuge in
Holland. Before the troubles
began, he had been a merchant in
Antwerp and had traded to the
Spanish colonies. From what he
had seen in the course of his
voyages he believed that those
colonies from which Spain drew
the greater part of her revenue
were so ill-defended that they
could be captured easily; and he
also believed that even a small
force of ships, with good
fighters on board of them, could
capture some of the treasure
fleets which in those days were
sent homeward from the colonies
to Spain. His plan, therefore,
was to organize a stock company
which should fit out a strong
naval force; and with that naval
force should take possession of
so much Spanish wealth that the
power of Spain would be broken
and the Netherlands would be
free. That was a patriotic
project but there was another
side to it that was not
patriotic. One of the strong
inducements which Usselinex
offered to make people buy stock
in his company was that very big
dividends would be paid when the
Spanish cities in America had
been captured and when the
Spanish treasure ships had been
brought home. The bad ending of
the West India Company was due
directly to that mixing of
patriotism and money-making.
Such an attempt to blend the
highest and purest motive for
human action with the lowest and
impurest motive for human action
was bound to come, as it did
come, to a miserable end. We
have a direct interest in that
ancient matter. Because the West
India Company was organized on
sordid lines, our city was
started badly and was badly
ruled.
Usselinex carried through his
project, and for a time the West
India Company was splendidly
successful. Rich conquests were
made in America; and still more
magnificent winnings came with
the capture by Admiral Peter
Heyn of the Spanish silver fleet
laden with so much treasure
that, to quote the company's own
report of the matter, "never did
any fleet bring to this or to
any other country so great a
prize." That big assertion was
justified by the facts. The
lowest estimate of the treasure
in the seventeen galleons
brought safe home to Holland was
twelve millions of guilders and
that is not far from being
equivalent in value to twelve
millions of our dollars of
today. But the men who won that
great treasure were not the
better for it. They were the
worse for it. Getting it so
turned their heads that they
took no further interest in
small matters, and either
neglected or mismanaged their
ordinary affairs. For the most
part they did both. Our little
colony which was of such small
importance that the name of New
Netherland does not appear in
the West India Company's charter
only came in for its share in
the general misrule: that
extended to the other colonies,
in Africa, in the West Indies,
and in the Brazils.
In the end, getting precisely
what it deserved to get, the
West India Company came to
miserable ruin. One after
another its valuable possessions
were lost to it through its own
weakness and incapacity; and all
that now remains in Dutch hands
of the principality that it
founded are the little islands
of St. Eustatius and Curacoa in
the West Indies, and the scrap
of territory in South America
known as Dutch Guiana, or
Surinam. This last has a
peculiar interest for us. When
the war between England and
Holland was ended an account of
that war will come later a
treaty was signed in the year
1667 that is known as the Treaty
of Breda; and by the terms of
that agreement the Dutch were
permitted to keep Surinam, in
return for permitting the
English to keep what then was
called New Netherland and what
thereafter was called New York.
The victories won by the West
India Company did have much to
do with breaking the power of
Spain and winning the
independence of the Netherlands;
but it mixed its patriotism with
its desire for money-making, and
so lost the glory that it
otherwise would have earned. Its
part in that splendid war was
the part that a sailor on board
a ship in a storm would take
should he refuse to help in
saving the ship unless he got
extra pay.
In the government of its
colonies the company showed
precisely the same selfishness
and the same greed that it
showed in the war. All that it
cared for was to make money out
of them; not a particle did it
ever manifest of the patriotism
that would have developed and
strengthened them and so added
to the strength of Holland by
giving them capable rulers and
liberal laws. A good government
must have much the same
qualities that a good man must
have. it must be honest, it must
be just, it must care for the
welfare of those dependent upon
it, it must protect the weak
from the oppression of the
strong. The West India Company
had not one of those good
qualities and that was why our
city and our colony were
governed so badly in their early
years.
As human nature has not changed
much since those days, it is
only by fighting all the time
for it that we can save our city
and our State from having just
as bad a government even now.
THOMAS A. JANVIER
Note: Thomas A.
Janvier is the author of "In Old
New York," "In Great Waters,"
"The Passing of Thomas," "In the
Sargasso Sea," "The Uncle of an
Angel," and "The Aztec Treasure
House."