Yesterday, at the meeting of the
Board of Health, President
Schultz submitted some
interesting facts regarding the
butchering business, together
with a history of the manner in
which it has always been
controlled by law. Upon the
adjournment of the Board the
president invited the members
and the reporters to accompany
himself and Capt. Lord, Chief,
of the Sanitary Police, upon an
inspecting tour of the
slaughter-pens.
Four carriages were in waiting
for the party. The first place
visited was No. 218 Mott-street.
This is a little stable-like
looking place, where, amid the
accumulated filth of weeks,
sundry men and boys were engaged
in dressing beef for the market.
The accommodations for drainage,
and consequently for
cleanliness, in this place
seemed especially bad. At Nos.
185, 189 and 193
Elizabeth-street were the
slaughter-houses, fat-boiling
establishment and hide curing
vats of Messrs. HAW, HANLIN AND
QUIMBY. In the rear, and
overlooking these premises, is
one of our large public schools.
It would soon to be impossible
to confine within so small a
compass so much filth and so
many disgusting odors. It is
beyond the power of words to
convey any idea of the intensely
filthy sights and smells there
presented, where living animals
are crowded into little narrow,
reeking pens, and compelled to
witness the slaughtering of
their fellows. Perhaps they
don't care much about that, but
when the effluvia arising from
these pens is sufficient to
knock the animals down, it
certainly is not the best
atmosphere for humanity to
breathe. Yet it is said that
this fat-melting establishment
has the most improved apparatus
for conducting the business and
consuming its own odors.
The hog-killing establishment of
J. Lockhart, No.146
Ludlow-street, was found in as
cleanly a condition as such a
place can be, but no butchering
had been done there for two
months. At Nos. 49, 53, 55, 57
and 60 First-avenue, occupying
nearly an entire block, are the
slaughter-houses of Messrs.
EISNER, KATZ, HARRINGTON and
WESTHEIMER, respectively. In
this block is killed and
butchered about one-quarter of
all the fresh meat consumed in
New-York, accounting in the
aggregate to between three and
five hundred beef cattle per
week, and sheep, calves, &c., in
proportion. While they are
conducted with cleanliness
compared with others visited
yesterday, they are necessarily
filthy and disgusting, more so
than they would be were the
accommodations for conducting
the business equal to the
demand. Councilman COSTELLO
keeps a little slaughter-pen in
the rear of No. 304 East
Twelfth-street. Although he had
not as he remarked "Killed a
bullock in two weeks," the place
was a most excellent one to get
away from. The sheep
slaughtering establishment of
David-Barreit, No. 17
Sixth-street, was the worst one
we visited its "offence was rank
and smelled," and so did all the
workman. Mr. J.G. BROWNING, at
Nos. 25 and 27 Sixth-street, has
converted an old church into a
cattle and sheep yard, whence
many butchers draw their supply.
It is, in all respects, a model
of neatness and cleanliness, as
far as such an institution can
be either neat or clean.
All these establishments are
located in the most densely
populated portions of the City,
are surrounded by long rows of
tenement houses, which are
filled to overflowing with men,
women and particularly children.
These latter congregate in
swarms around the slaughter pens
and revel in the filth there
accumulated. To describe in
detail what we saw would be to
sicken our readers, and make
them foreswear the use of meat
forever. We had never dreamed of
such a conglomeration of
disgusting sights and smells.
The "Augean stables" were,
compared to New York
slaughter-house, what a side
show is to a big circus. Let the
general forms in which we speak
of them suffice. In so appalling
we do not mean to say that any
one is particularly more
objectionable than another, they
are, one and all, simply
horrible_necessarily horrible if
you please, but none the less
objectionable because necessary.
The slaughtering of animals
within the City limits is
detrimental to the public
health, and morals as well, and
should be prohibited. With the
slaughtering business there
follows its attendant nuisances,
fat-boiling, and hide-dressing .
They must eventually be removed,
for a patient public cannot be
imposed upon forever. The
abattoirs suggested by the Board
of Health, and now in course of
construction, are what the City
needs and what must eventually
be used for all slaughtering
purposes, and these
air-poisoning and
pestilence-breeding places
removed.
It is but justice to the
gentlemen named above, and to
the butchers generally, to say
that they have received the
suggestions of the Health
officers with courtesy, and have
striven to make their places as
unobjectionable as their
accommodations will permit. But
the objection does not lie with
them as individuals, but with
their business. Their calling is
a nuisance from its very nature,
and should be conducted where it
is least objectionable. It is
natural that they should object
to the abattoir, for the reason
that they will be forced to
abandon the property they now
hold. But eventually they will
be driven beyond the City
limits, and it would be wise for
them to accept "the situation,"
make a virtue of necessity, and
secure the best accommodations
they can as speedily as
possible. The visit of the
Board, yesterday, was for the
purpose of enabling the members
to act understandingly when they
come to consider the resolution
submitted by the President.