The Jewish dietary laws were not
instituted consciously for
hygienic reasons.
Notwithstanding this, the actual
hygienic and sanitary aspects of
these laws must form an
essential basis for their
scientific evaluation, and it is
from this standpoint that they
are reviewed in this article.
The Hebrew definition__"Kasher"
denotes any foodstuff which by
virtue of its salutary nature is
conducive to the proper
nourishment of the human economy
without giving rise to any
disturbance after being
ingested. "Treifa" signifies
anything, which, possessing more
or less toxic or unsalubrious
properties, is unable to sustain
the wants of the organism, and
is also instrumental in the
possible creation of symptoms
directly or indirectly
attributable to the food
partaken.
In short, "Kasher" means
wholesome and sanitary, while
"Treifa" conveys the idea of
anything that is directly
unhealthy, toxic, and
insufficient for the needs of
the human body, or is indirectly
capable of engendering ill
effects.
The following constitutes a
discussion of the interdicted
articles of diet barred from the
dietary of the Jew. In order to
do this it is necessary to
resort to a consideration of
certain zoological features
bearing on this question as well
as theories belonging to the
realm of evolution.
Evolutionary zoology teaches
that animal organisms of a
simple anatomical construction
are less adapted to alimentary
purposes than those of a complex
constitution; hence the various
Reptilia, Mollusca, and
Crustacea are not only
insufficient as articles of
diet, but also give rise to
manifold forms of intoxication.
A variety of micro-organisms
infest these lower forms of
animal life. These have a weak
resisting power and are endowed
with a low vitality. Animal
organisms of this type are
decomposed with great facility
and become a prey to bacteria.
The simpler an animal is
constructed the less fit it is
for the sustenance of the human
body, the speedier it undergoes
decomposition, and the more
prone it is to create
constitutional disturbances.
There are four species of locust
which the Bible permits as food;
but their nomenclature is so
involved and their exact
identity is so doubtful that we
are at a loss as to the kind of
locust specifically meant.
The tortoise is known to carry
in its crusty covering a number
of microorganisms, and there are
cases on record of deaths which
are traceable to the eating of
turtle flesh. The snail, mussel,
and the different varieties of
crabs are species to which the
above is equally applicable.
The Bible forbids the
consumption of fish which do not
possess fins and scales. Here
again we are forced to resort to
the evolutionary doctrine, which
teaches that all aquatic
creatures which have squamous
tunics are of a higher type than
those which have no such
appendages. The fishes having
fins stand high on the ladder of
evolution. To reason from an a
priori assertion, it would seem
that they are more suitable as
an article of diet than those
that are deprived of the above
requisites. They are easy of
digestion and of greater
nutritive value than the
scaleless inhabitants of deep
sea or fresh water. An adequate
example is the classical fact
repeatedly rehearsed in all
books on hygiene and sanitation,
namely, the communicability of
typhoid fever through the medium
of the oyster, which belongs to
the order of of mollusca, an
intermediary group of the above
class. The eel is another member
of the foregoing genus; it is a
so-called creeping fish, is
difficult of digestion and
although relished by many, can
lay no claim to being a
wholesome and nutritious food.
Another very important feature
which must be mentioned in
connection with the discussion
of animal evolution is that the
primordial organisms have almost
all subsisted upon a flesh or
protoplasm-devouring regimen;
they have all been carnivorous
animals. As they, however,
ascend the scale of progression
we find that they have also
acquired the tendency to subsist
under vegetable diet; they were
gradually transformed into
herbivorous animals. We know
that the fiber of animals, the
recipients of an exclusive
nitrogenous food, is extremely
tenacious, requiring much heat
to render it pliant and
masticable before it can be
pronounced fit to reach the
table. On the other hand,
animals which depend upon
vegetables for their nutrition
possess delicate and tender
muscular fibers, demanding
comparatively little culinary
effort at preparation. The
latter class of animals harbor a
special digestive apparatus, and
require very little labor in
digesting their food. From this
we may easily deduce that the
herbivorous animals are of a
higher type, and thus more
adapted to the diet than the
carnivorous animals, whose fiber
does not lend itself as readily
to culinary purposes; this would
substantiate the evolutionary
doctrine that complexity tends
toward progression, and
simplicity of organization and
structure indicates a primitive
developmental type.
Mammalia permitted
dietetically must be both
ruminant and cloven-footed. One
prerequisite alone does not
suffice. These species of
animals are all herbivorous.
The muscular fiber of the
rodents such as the hare and
rabbit is very tenacious.
Special preparations are
necessary before they can be
regarded as a fit dish. Their
flesh is one of the most
indigestible of animal tissues,
and, as such is biblically
prohibited.
One of the most dangerous,
intractable, and incurable of
diseases is "trichiniasis" which
affects the swine due to its
habitat of squalor and filth.
Thelminthiae, or worms, as
taenia solium and taenia
mediocanellata (different
varieties of tapeworm), as well
as other parasitic forms may
infest the intestines of those
who partake of the flesh of this
animal.
Domestic fowls exhibit delicate
muscular fibers, while those in
the wild state yield a
comparatively tenacious
musculature. The flesh of the
domestic chicken, for example,
is more savory and digestible
than that of the wild duck, the
latter being an omnivorous fowl,
while the former is a
herbivorous bird. The following
birds are pronounced unclean:
eagle, ossifrage, osprey,
vulture, raven, ostrich,
night-hawk, cuckoo, hawk, owl,
swan, pelican, gier-eagle,
stork, heron, and lapwing.
Albumen is an essential and
necessary ingredient upon which
life and its successful
continuation depends. Milk
harbors the most digestible form
of albumen, viz.,
casein-albumen. Animal albumen,
which is found in every animal
texture without exception,
necessitates a greater effort on
the part of the stomach and
requires more time for its
complete digestion than
casein-albumen.
Hence, a diet of mixed albumens
both animal and liquid albumen
(the latter as represented in
milk)__taken at one meal burdens
the digestive capacity of the
stomach, and puts a heavier
peptogenic or digestive task
upon it. The consequences
accrued from it may in time
assume formidable proportions,
such as apepsia or indigestion,
atony of the stomach, and a host
of manifold disorders of the
digestive tract. An individual
partaking of the various forms
of albumen at one meal would
eventually encounter some
distress or disturbance in the
digestive organs, which may
subsequently lead to more
serious consequences.
There is a disease afflicting
both man and beast, which in the
former constitutes a terrible
scourge. This affliction is
rightly termed "the white plague
of mankind," Tuberculosis. One
of the potent sources of
infection is the meat and milk
of consumptive animals. The cow
is peculiarly susceptible to the
bacillus of tuberculosis.
Inspection in this direction is
as yet imperfectly carried out.
However, the system of ritual
meat inspection as practiced by
the Jews is the most thorough,
painstaking and efficient
extant, as it prevents infected
meat gaining access to the
butcher shop and hence to the
table.
The Bible also interdicts the
use of cattle which have
perished from disease, because
as soon as an animal succumbs to
disease of whatsoever kind, it
becomes the harboring place of
numberless and nameless low
forms of animal life.
Meat kept over three days is
very rarely used by the Jews,
unless the same has been well
washed, and then only in
exceptional instances. No such
thing as indefinite or prolonged
refrigeration or cold storage is
permitted. The meat that comes
to the Jewish table is fresh,
clean, wholesome, and free from
pathogenic organisms. In short,
it is "kasher."
The profound wisdom of the Bible
becomes apparent from the
foregoing. Its ordinances aim at
prevention. Its precepts are in
accordance with the doctrines of
modern sanitation, and its
regulations compatible with the
dictates of hygiene. The Bible
is the pioneer of the sanitary
sciences of today.