A gifted writer, the Rev. Dr.
S.D. McConnell, in a recent
article has undertaken to
outline the causes contributing
to the antipathy of Gentiles
toward Jews, and while the
causes as therein stated are
undoubtedly very potent factors,
yet they appear insignificant
compared to the great basic
principles underlying the whole
question and that are coeval
with the formation of the race.
Let us examine some of these
principles, and trace their
progress and development during
centuries to find the origin of
that hostility and aversion,
that, in many quarters of the
globe, is as intense and
virulent today as it was in its
early manifestation. The Jew in
common with his Oriental
neighbors, was compelled by the
circumstances of his environment
to associate in families or
groups of families, called
tribes, the better to tend his
herds and flocks, and to protect
both himself and them from those
predatory hordes that infested
the vast territory over which he
roamed. Monotheism was the
system of worship and belief,
and upon it a superstructure of
theocratic government was
founded whose organization, with
the growth and material
development of the race, assumed
a despotic proportion, and
around which all the affairs of
life were made to revolve.
Hence almost from the
commencement of the organic life
of this people, the Jew assumed
and may fairly be entitled to
claim, a superiority over the
polytheistic people among whom
he dwelt or with whom he came in
contact during his migrations;
we may be sure this was not
ostentatiously displayed, for
among these he seems to have
been regarded as a desirable
ally and friend, and to command
respect and confidence; nor was
it until he waxed strong and
influential that the increasing
assumption of religious
superiority attracted
unfavorable notice. This
assumption was fostered by his
teachers of the priesthood,
reinforced by the mandate of his
rulers, themselves often high
priests as well as kings. Thus
early he assumed and announced
himself as a chosen people, the
elect of his God, and his
literature teemed with
statements to that effect,
prophecies were made and
promises given on the
stipulation of his steadfastness
to the laws of his organization,
and more particularly to the
maintenance of that "aloofness"
always and everywhere insisted
upon as the cardinal principle
of his religious creed.
Like all pastoral people, he
was contemplative, imaginative,
and to a remarkable degree prone
to introspection; the stars, and
his flocks and herds were often
for extended periods his only
companions, and his meditations
were, as a consequence, tinged
with that beautiful mysticism so
constantly present in his
writings. Assuming that he was
under the special protection of
his God__Jehovah__that He
exercised over him and for him a
direct and parental authority,
that He rewarded his constancy
and punished his transgressions,
he soon became in fact as well
as in name a peculiar people.
And so, through good fortune and
ill, amid prosperity and
adversity, in freedom and in
captivity, this one enduring,
ever present living idea
remained to him an immutable
truth; his selection and
election by the God he worshiped
as His especial care and charge!
he called upon Him in his
adversity in language beautiful
and poetic, he invoked His
vengeance upon his enemies, he
offered praises, trophies and
sacrifices to Him in time of
victory, and all that he did was
by and through and for his God.
His leaders, always skillful in
appealing to human nature,
uttered prophesies, and gave
promise for his future
happiness, always distinctly
religious; and to this
fundamental principle the Jew
has, as a whole, been true,
remaining steadfast amid all the
vicissitudes that subsequently
overwhelmed him.
When the new religion came, and
with it the overturning of old
and cherished customs, he was at
first amused and later
scandalized, for the doctrine
was directed straight toward
him, and he saw much that had
grown venerable by long practice
held up to obloquy. The new
religion throve and numbered
many converts, and after the
death of its Founder it took on
added impulse from persecution,
and Christianity became an
established religion, destined
to a marvelous growth, until it
in turn should be rent in sunder
by the forces inherent in the
human mind. But while this was
in progress the Jew had a hard
time of it. He was by no means
singular in manifesting a strong
clannish disposition, all of the
Orientals possessed it to a
large degree, as well as the
Celts, the Franks and the Latins
generally; but the Jew differed
from others in its manifestation
in this, that with him the
segregation was a necessary
corollary of his religious
tenets, the corner stone of all
his theocratic superstructure,
and hence, too, the Jew was no
proselyter; it did not matter to
him what others did or thought
his concern was for himself.
Many of his race were coerced
into joining in other modes of
worship, both before and after
Christianity, but he still
turned his face to the ark of
his covenant, much as his
Gentile prototype turns to his;
but the Jew rarely turned his
back upon his religion, for to
repudiate that would have been
equivalent to denying almost the
reason for his existence.
As Christianity spread, and was
either adopted as an auxiliary
or embraced exclusively, the
antagonism to the Jew increased,
until finally, in the zenithy of
its power, it assumed the
proportions of a cardinal
principle of the faith, was a
Jew rich? his possessions were
fair spoil, and went to swell
the measure of their rapacity;
was he learned, his knowledge
was utilized to the same end,
or, as most frequently happened,
was made the occasion of his
sacrifice to superstitious fear
and ignorance, and as the
organization of the Christian
sect became more and more
perfect, and its ramifications
more and more extended, the
measure of his cup of bitterness
grew until all sense of
proportion was lost if it was
intended as a punishment for an
alleged crime against humanity,
or rather that portion of
humanity represented by the
gospel of love.
In this extremity he was thrown
back again upon himself, and the
very efforts put forth so
strenuously to destroy him only
served to stimulate him to
greater efforts to survive and
made the racial unity more
complete. To those who with an
unbiased mind contemplate his
history, often pathetic in the
extreme, and apprehend the
magnificent devotion to a
religious principle he has
steadily maintained, emotions of
intense admiration are aroused
at the spectacle of those
enduring qualities of loyalty he
has so unwaveringly manifested,
and should operate to overcome
those prejudices born of
ignorance, nurtured in bigotry,
and perpetuated in malice, that
have been so persistently
maintained.
With the advent of the
Anglo-Saxon, whose power was to
dominate the world, and the
revolution that forever
shattered the rule of the
Christian hierarchy, the
liberation of a long pent-up
intelligence and the consequent
growth of knowledge, together
with the formation of
innumerable sects on the ruins
of the primitive Christian
faith, the prospects of the Jew
Took on a more cheerful aspect,
and while the prejudice and
antagonism was to continue, the
intensity of its virulence was
modified, and from a reluctant
sufferance developed slowly but
surely, toleration, and an
increasing measure of
liberality.
From this time on, the Jew was
permitted to extend his field of
usefulness among his fellow
human beings, hitherto
restrained by rigid and
tyrannical enactment, to the
narrow sphere of merchandizing
and money matters which his
traducers affected to despise,
but never neglected to avail
themselves in full measure; and
thus he early became expert in
both, not from selection, but
from dire necessity, and these
qualities abide with him still,
and are still esteemed a
reproach!
That the Jew will ever
assimilate, and lose his
identity in the races among whom
he has been scattered seems
improbable from our knowledge of
his past, and his regeneration
as a nation, with his return to
the "Land of promise" equally
chimerical. Rather it is to be
assumed that he has come to
regard the situation as it
confronts him in that
philosophical spirit in which he
has been so well schooled and in
which he practices so admirably.
Here in these United States, his
condition socially, politically
and financially, has attained
its highest development, and how
nobly he has responded to the
influences of freedom in its
most exalted conception
thousands of his race are
demonstrating, and thousands
among whom he dwells in peace
and amity attest.
Whether he will ever make
overtures for a closer relation
with those who have for so long
a period esteemed him so meanly,
whether the influences that have
so operated upon his hereditary
antagonists to the remarkable
improvement in his own lot, will
react to any extent upon his
inborn religious convictions to
that end, is a problem for the
future.
J.E.RUSSELL, M.D. Brooklyn, May
11, 1901.