At Two o'clock yesterday
afternoon, John Monaghan,
Michael Quinn, and James Kerwin,
were arraigned before Justice
Dailey, on the charge preferred
against them of robbing and
ravishing the three women, Mrs.
Ellen Walker and the Misses
Margaret lacy and Anna Campbell,
residing at No. 202 North
Seventh street, E.D. Mr. Charles
Briggs, counsel for defendants,
being absent at the opening of
the case, the continuation of
Mrs. Walker's cross-examination
was postponed, and Miss Lacy
called to the stand. Her
testimony was as follows:
Miss Lacy's Testimony
Margaret Lacy sworn; I reside at
No. 202 North Seventh street
with my sister Ellen Walker; I
work at vest-making with my
sister; on the morning of
December 2d I was a-bed; I
retired at about 10 o'clock on
the previous evening; my sister
awoke me by crying "murder;" a
man had hold of her arm; I was
in bed at that time with my
sister and Anna Campbell; I saw
five men in the room; I
recognized Monaghan as one of
them; also Michael Quinn; when I
awoke one of them seized me by
the arm; I asked him what he
wanted, when he said he would
show me; he said they came in
there for satisfaction; I began
to shout for "help," whereupon
he told me that if I should make
any alarm that he would mash my
"snoot" on my face; the person
who said that is not arrested;
Monaghan pinched me on the foot
and took out a knife, saying:
"which one is it? I will cut her
throat right away, if she don't
keep silent," one of the party
then took a smoothing-iron and
said he would scatter our
brains, if we did not make less
noise; the one who said that is
not present; they said they came
to strip us of some of our fire
clothing and furniture, and that
as soon as we got more they
would take that also.
They said that they intended to
come on the week following; but
if they did not come another
gang would; then one came in
with a lamp, when I told them
not to take our clothing; he
said "Oh! yes, we'll leave it;"
Monaghan put his hands over my
eyes when the man came in with
the lamp; Monaghan was the
principal, the ringleader, I
should judge; he took his hat
and put it over my sister's
eyes; several others of the
party then caught him by the
hair, pulling him back towards
the wall, and calling him hard
names; they came in and asked
where that biggest son of a b___
(Monaghan) was; he was on the
bed at the time; he was rubbing
his knife (white handled,
straight blade) against the
wall; he then handed his knife
to Anna Campbell and told her to
cut his throat for she would
only have him sent up for 5
years in the morning; there were
two others on the bed at this
time, one on the floor and one
by the door; the parties on the
bed (here witness burst into
tears) the persons of all three
of us were violated; defendant,
Monaghan, was one of the parties
who violated us; I think Quinn
was also one of them on the bed;
he was holding me down on the
bed, and said that if I knew
when I was well off I had better
keep still; I was trying to
escape from the bed; I offered
resistance and cried out; when I
put my hand on his face I felt
some pimples; he said "Oh, you
are feeling of me, are you, to
know me in that way!" he took my
arm and said he would break it
if I did not take my hand off
his face; my object was to feel
if he had hair on it; I rubbed
my hand across his forehead and
down on his face: I felt the
pimples on his forehead; did not
feel any hair on his face; I
told them to go out, when
Monaghan got a potato-smasher
and struck me over the eye; he
kicked and walked on me! he then
tried to draw the rings from my
ears; I asked him if he would
not let me have my ear-rings, as
my mother had given them to me;
at this instant one of the party
appeared at the door with a
knife, when I said, "Oh, he is
going to kiss us;" he had a
middling sized knife; three went
out of the room, and one
remained sitting on the floor,
watching us; we asked him if
they were going to kill us, and
he said they would silence us by
daylight if we didn't keep
still; he sat there about
fifteen minutes, when Monaghan
and the two others came back.
They asked us how we liked night
burglars and asked us to kiss
them; Monaghan asked this and I
told him to take all we had, but
to spare our lives; he said he
did not know whether they would
or not, but if they did we might
consider ourselves lucky; I
asked him if he had a sister or
mother, that he would like any
one to come in in that way, he
said his sister was a common
w___, and his mother an imp of
hell!. All went out save one,
who said he would get me all the
things back again; he then went
out and returned in a short time
(about 3 minutes) with 1 dress
and 3 pairs of shoes, saying,
"there's all your things now, we
have not touched any" he said
there were three men lying drunk
on the floor in the outside
room; this party is not present;
he left shortly afterwards. When
my sister got up in about five
minutes afterwards, we followed
her upstairs; the man living
upstairs would not let us in at
first, thinking that we were the
men; he let us in however, and
said that he had heard us cry
"murder", we had found our three
trunks on the floor of the front
room, just before passing up
stairs to Mr. and Mrs. Ling; we
were not dressed at this time;
it was daylight in a short time
after that; we remained there
until about 7 o'clock, A.M.
I was twice ravished by one
person; he is not present; all
my sister's property was taken
away, consisting of two dresses,
under-clothing, hoop-skirt,
stockings, hat, veil, clock,
ring from her finger, (which she
said Monaghan took) and
chandeliers from the mantel
piece; my property taken,
consisted of 2 dresses (silk and
linen,) black silk sack, cloth
basque, set of furs,
underclothing, 1/2 dozen
handkerchiefs, 3 towels, two
table cloths, breast-pin, sleeve
buttons- all belonging to me;
unfinished under-clothing was
also taken; also, 72 vests_24
woolen and 48 linen; 20 of the
woolen ones were made, 4
partially; the linen ones were
unfinished.
Justice Dailey__You were
speaking of having seen Quinn
before__state where it was?
Mr. Flynn (Quinn and Kerwin's
counsel,) objected to the
question. Objection overruled.
WITNESS__I have seen
Monaghan often standing at the
corner of North 7th and 6th
streets; have also seen Quinn
standing on the corner; they
have said "ahem" as we passed
down North 7th street; also,
"these are two nice young girls
we would like to ring in there"
on Thanksgiving evening had
company to dinner; they were
Robert Ellison and William Wood
of New York; they went away
about 8 o'clock, when my sister
and myself accompanied them to
the stoop; we said, "Good night,
Bob and Bill'; Monaghan, Quinn,
and two others, who were
standing near the house,
imitated us; I cannot recognize
the two with Monaghan and Quinn;
they said to our company, "If we
catch you over here again, Bob
and Billy, we will club you.:
They said it loud enough for us
to hear only; they said to us,
"You had better get in there or
we will chuck you in the street
and take your fine clothing and
furniture from you," they said
they would come in on the week
following and strip us of
everything we had; we told them
that they laid a finger upon us,
we would have them arrested;
they then said, "I guess the
police will have a poor show
here." They all spoke; they were
very close together and stood in
front of our stoop; the men also
abused the woman living below
us. (Witness is shown and
identifies the vests, trimming
and other property, recovered on
Monday evening, by the
Forty-fifth Precinct Police.) I
recognize them as the property
taken from my house.
Cross-examination was suspended
for the present, whereupon
Justice Dailey called Sergeant
Bunco to the stand, thus:
"Sergeant Bunce, come here at
once!"
The Sergeant's Testimony
Sergeant George Bunce, sworn__I
reside at No. 271 South first
street and am attached to the
45th precinct; I found the
property in question in the
cellar of a house in North 8th
street, south side, between 6th
and 7th; I saw Miss Monaghan
there; she did not tell me that
her brother (the prisoner) lived
there; I found the goods in the
front cellar in a small
apartment near the foundation
walls. I found them at 5 1/2
o'clock last evening; I went
with officer Walsh into the
cellar from the inside of the
house; there was a dark dress
over the goods, so that one
could hardly see them; these
articles were all in one place.
At this stage of the
proceedings, the hearing was
adjourned until Thursday
morning, at 9 o'clock.
Messrs. Olmstead and Newton
appeared for the prosecution;
Mr. Chas. M. Briggs for
Monaghan, and Mr. Jno. M. Flynn
(assigned by the court) for
Quinn and Kerwin.