Thousands of people who live in
New York have never seen
Blackwell's Island ; and quite
as many, I venture to assert,
cannot tell where it is. They
hear it mentioned day after day
; they know it is devoted to
penal institutions, and
somewhere in the vicinity of the
Metropolis. But whether it is in
the Sound, or East or North
river, or in the Bay, they are
wholly
ignorant.
Time and again I have heard my
fellow-passengers, residents of
this city, inquire, while
steaming to Providence or Boston
through the East river, "What
place is that?" as they passed
the pleasant-looking spot. And
they were much surprised when
informed that it was the
notorious Blackwell's island.
To the poor loafers, vagrants,
and small rogues of the
Metropolis,the Island, as it is
called by way of distinction,
is better known. They have
learned its exact location and
peculiarities by sad experience
; and they are continually
refreshing their memories by
repeated incarcerations. I say
the poor loafers and small
rogues, for the prosperous and
great ones are clad in purple
and fine linen, instead of
striped uniforms, and go to Long
Branch and Europe instead of
Blackwell's island.
Men not one-tenth as guilty as
the dwellers amid Fifth-Avenue
luxury or Grammercy-Park
splendors have passed half their
lives on the island, at Sing
Sing, and Auburn ; and the
wealthy and superior scoundrels
have wondered meanwhile at the
depravity
of the poor.
The island, the lower end of
which is opposite Sixty-first
Street in the East river is one
of the pleasantest spots, to the
outward eye, in the vicinity of
the Metropolis. During seven or
eight months of the year it is
as green, and cool, and
picturesque a place as one could
desire to linger in. The skies
are so fair and spotless ; the
air is so soft and
fresh ; the water so smooth and
clear around it, that it appears
quite the ideal of a Summer
resort. Few pass it on steamers
without admiring it, and
declaring what a charming abode
those villains have ; forgetting
their own, perhaps, greater
sins, and that the crime of the
villains is only misfortune by
another name.
The early history of the island
is 'involved in mystery and
tradition. It was a favorite
pleasure ground with the
Indians, it is said, and the
early Dutch settlers celebrated
their festal days there with a
simplicity characteristic of
their fatherland. In 1823 it
passed into the hands of James
Blackwell, an Englishman, who
occupied it with his family as a
farm for a number of years, and
from whom it received its
present name. About thirty-five
years ago it was purchased by
the City, and has since been
employed as a prison for the
violators of municipal
ordinances.
The buildings are of gray
granite, with a few frame
outhouses, well constructed,
spacious, airy, and as
comfortable as such
outhouses, well constructed,
spacious, airy, and as
comfortable as such places can
be. They seem decidedly
desirable at a distance, vastly
preferable to the over-crowded
tenement houses of the Fourth,
Sixth, and Eighteenth wards, and
induce one to believe that
therein mercy tempers justice.
But prisons are never handsome
to persons confined in them ;
and he who
imagines the island attractive
can have his illusion dispelled
by a short confinement.
The buildings are the hospital,
workhouse, lunatic asylum,
almshouse, and penitentiary. The
indigent and the criminal have
different quarters, but are
treated in much the same manner.
There is a species of worldly
justice in this; for poverty is
the only crime society cannot
forgive.
The men and women are kept apart
in all the buildings, though
they contrive to elude vigilance
and get together often, as is
shown by the fact that children
are born there whose mothers
have been on the island for more
than a year.
The paupers, and criminals, and
lunatics vary in number from
three to five thousand all told
; and they increase every year,
so that some of the departments
are greatly crowded and
unhealthy in consequence. The
care of the paupers and
criminals is as good as could be
expected; but it is anything but
what it ought to be ; and
flagrant acts of injustice,
oppression,
and even cruelty are not
uncommon.
It is usual, in writing about
superintendents,
overseers,wardens, and turnkeys
of charitable and penal
institutions, to speak of them
as humane and sympathetic, which
they very rarely are. I have
seen a good deal of this class,
and I have often found them
hard, unfeeling and tyrannical,
and not unfrequently brutal and
cruel to the last degree. Their
position is
not calculated to develop the
sensibilities or refine the
sentiments, and they do not
enter upon their duties with any
surplus of charity or
tenderness. To expect the
cardinal virtues of them is
unreasonable. If they were fine
or gentle natures, they would
not be there ; for saints do not
gravitate to the custodianship
of prisons and poor-houses, any
more than vestals do to stews.
I seldom see men or women in
such a place, particularly the
former, without an instinctive
shrinking from them. Their
faces, their manner, their
voices betray them generally for
what they are. I cannot but pity
the unfortunate committed to
their keeping, subjected to
their power.
The attaches of Blackwells
island are not exceptions. I
have read their praises in the
papers, from the pens of partial
reporters ; but those praises
were for the most part either
the blunders of ignorance or the
result of premeditated
misrepresentation.
The hospital is a stone
building, 400 by 50 feet, and
usually contains 200 to 400
patients suffering from every
form of disease. They are fairly
cared for ; their beds clean ;
their diet wholesome, and
medical attention good. They are
ranged on little iron bedsteads
in long rows, and are
melancholy-looking enough ; for
little intelligence or moral
culture illumines their pale and
wasted faces.
The mortality among them is
large, because they have abused
themselves or been abused sadly
by severity of circumstance.
Many of them have been drunkards
and outcasts from their birth ;
others have inherited broken
constitutions and ancestral
disease ; and all have come into
being out of parallel with
nature — organization and
destiny against them.
Death can have few terrors for
them (it is always less fearful
when near than at a distance);
and I do not marvel they breathe
their last with perfect
resignation, or that they pass
out of life cursing all that has
been and is to come.
Sickness is ever painful. But
sickness there, without hope,
without means, without sympathy,
without future, without friends,
must be agony unrelieved.
Their logic must be this: What
have they to dread from change ?
What other sphere can be worse
than this to them ? If God be
powerful, He must gradually lift
their burthens. If He be good,
He will not punish them ; for
they have already suffered
beyond their sin. And if He be
not, then they will not be
either. What then have they to
fear ?
The workhouse much resembles the
other buildings. It is gray,
granite, grim. Its inmates vary
from 600 to 800, fully half of
whom are women ; though females
would be the fitter word,
inasmuch as woman suggests
gentleness, tenderness, and
lovableness, —qualities in which
the island is deplorably
deficient.
Persons are sent there for minor
offenses, such as drunkenness,
disorderly conduct, carrying
concealed weapons, vagrancy, and
the like. Very few of the
inmates that have not been there
again and again. They are
sentenced for 30, 60, or 90
days, and at the end of this
term they are discharged only to
be brought back for a similar
offense before the week is
fairly gone.
A number of the men are employed
at trades.They make clothes, or
shoes or brooms ; but most of
them are engaged in quarrying or
farming upon the island. They
assist in repairing the
different structures and raise
vegetables for home consumption.
The women make hoop-skirts and
braid straw ; do the necessary
cleaning, and wash and iron for
the other prisoners and paupers.
Many seem quite contented, and
are very different creatures
from what they are when
intoxicated ; intoxication
usually being the cause of their
commitment. Some of the men and
women have been sent to the
island 30, 40, even 50 times,
and are doomed to die there.
They have no restraining,no
reforming influences ; and they
return to their old ways and
habits by the same law that
impels the tides of the sea.
The almshouse includes forty
acres, almost a third of the
entire island, and has 800 to
1,000 inhabitants; the men
generally being in the majority.
Both sexes are worthless
creatures, and their
surroundings remind one of the
perpetual palaver of Mrs.
Gummidge, whose constant
apprehension was, that she would
be "sent to the House." Their
advanced age is particularly
noticeable, and you wonder how
such poverty and distress can
have sustained life so long.
They are with rare exceptions
extremely ignorant ; have been
born to the fate they follow ;
have always had for familiar
companions stupidity, squalor
and sin.
Nineteen-twentieths of them are
foreigners, the Irish being the
most largely represented. And at
least half of them came paupers
to our shores. Not a few,
however, were once industrious
and honest, and have been
prevented from earning a
livelihood by loss of health or
some accident that has maimed
them.
The baby department attached to
the alms-house has usually about
200 little children who have
either been taken there with
their mothers, or found without
parents. They are generally from
a few months to two or three
years old, and are great
favorites with and pets of the
aged, and even the younger
women. Such is the maternal
instinct of the sex that no
deprivation,nor suffering, nor
adversity, nor degradation can
suppress it wholly.
Ill-natured stories are afloat
that some of the infants are,
strictly speaking, home
productions; but those who are
acquainted with the purity and
continence of the attache's will
not be slow to pronounce such
stories vile slanders.
The penitentiary is an enormous
building, and contains at
present about 600 inmates — all
masculine. They are employed
very much as their companions in
the workhouse, though they are
more closely watched, and the
discipline is more severe. They
rise at 6 in the morning, and
after breakfast, they begin
their tasks and labor until
nearly 6 in the evening. When
they
have taken their not very savory
supper, they are locked up in
their cells over night. They are
attired in striped uniforms, and
for refractory conduct they are
put on bread and water diet and
confined in dark dungeons. Most
of the criminals are ruffians
and thieves who have been
committed for serious assaults,
stabbing, shooting and stealing.
They are a hopeless and
graceless set, the greater part
at least, and are usually fitted
there for the higher honors of
Sing-Sing.
Very many of them are quite
young, and the generality in
good health and of excellent
physique. But their faces,
especially their eyes, indicate
their character, and strengthen
faith in the truth of
physiognomy. You can see now and
then, a strange mixture of
cunning and boldness, of
restlessness and desperation in
their repulsive countenances,
and you feel those men
are capable of any crime under
temptation or opportunity. A
strange, sad place is
Blackwell's island. After going
there you are relieved when you
return on the ferry and feel the
breeze from the sea Blowing
through your hair as if to
purify you from the unwholesome
atmosphere you have just
breathed. You look back at the
island, and all its beauty is
gone. Never again
does it seem picturesque ; for
you see through its outside down
to its black and cankered heart.