On the southern shore of Staten
Island, at what is known as
Seguine Point, there rises from
the beach a small stone sea wall
which extends for little more
than a dozen rods. This protects
from the inundating waters a
small plot of ground surrounded
by an unpainted picket fence.
Inside this enclosure little
straggling boards mark some
hundreds of low turf-covered
mounds. Here lie the ashes of
those unfortunates who have
fallen victims to contagious
diseases after reaching this
port. The little plot of land is
called the "Old Quarantine
Burying-ground." But it seems
that even in this secluded
corner, where the unfruitful
fields of southern Staten Island
slope slowly down to the water's
edge, the unknown dead are
grudged their neglected graves.
The people who live in the
neighborhood have for many years
strenuously objected to having
the ground put to this use, and
have made strong and even
unlawful endeavors toward the
removal from this spot of the
remains deposited there. But the
agitation of this subject,
although often revived, soon
dies out again, and it seems as
though these few neglected bones
would be allowed to quietly
crumble on where they were
originally buried.
One afternoon recently a
reporter of The Times picked his
way along the red, muddy road
that leads from Prince's Bay
Station down to the water. After
walking for quite a distance
around some marshy land close
tot he beach, the old
burying-ground was reached. In
the centre of this plot stand a
few gnarled, misshaped trees
with withered branches. Around
these is a miniature forest of
tall, leafless brush-wood. No
care has been taken in the
laying out of the graves, so
that the streets and avenues in
this little city of the dead are
winding and crooked. The small
white-painted boards that mark
the graves are all numbered, but
only a very small proportion are
lettered. There is but one
marble slab in the whole
burying-ground. This indicates
the spot where the remains of
Hypolite Reybaud were interred.
The inscription on this marble
tablet is "died August 16,
188o." At the other end of the
same grave is the board
originally placed there, and
which was numbered 280. No. 262
has marked in pencil below the
figures the inscription, "James
Wharton, died June 19, 1880."
This grave is covered with sea
shells, and is the only one that
bears marks of having been
recently decorated. On one of
the boards is marked "242. James
Reilly." R.T. Pinkham was
interred at 232 and Roigry Riba
at No. 247. Mrs. M.A. Ferrer was
buried at No. 248.
Few of the other boards bear any
inscription beyond the mere
number of the grave. The highest
number is 269. No. 94has been
split in halves, which have
fallen apart, and No. 142
appears to have been on fire at
some time. Several of the boards
have become decayed and have
fallen, and many are missing.
Over one of the mounds is a bush
on which are clusters of
blood-red berries, and a portion
of the thicket has grown up over
some of the unmarked graves. A
tall, slender sprig of green
rises from one of these unkempt
hillocks, and contrasts strongly
with the dull, sickly looking
brush around it. The rotten wood
of a small decayed tree lies
among the graves where it
appears to have recently fallen.
Nearly all of the graves have
been dug on the southern side of
the burying-ground, toward the
shore end of which lie the
turf-covered foundations of a
building which was burned down
years ago. Near this is an open
cistern half filled with
stagnant water. No attempt seems
to have been made recently to
clear up the little plot.
The low lands of Staten Island
to the westward look almost like
a barren and inhospitable waste.
The beach is coarse and covered
with stones. Here and there are
pieces of refuse that have been
cast up by the flood tide. The
surf has become partially
discolored by red dirt, and in
that condition its appearance is
far from attractive. But a scene
of beauty presents itself tot he
eastward. Numerous craft at
anchor or in motion, with the
sunlight striking a slant upon
the white sails, stud the broad
expansive sheet of water which
extends out of sight to where it
unites with the ocean. Fishermen
can be seen at work in their
boats and along the shore at
some distance to the southward.
Across the bay the Highlands of
Navesink rise out of the water,
and seem to guard the approach
from the ocean. The broad,
bright sheet of rippling water,
skirted by rising grounds and
dotted by snow-white patches of
canvas, presents a strange
contrast tot he low, flat lands
that extend tot he westward as
far as the eye can reach, and
the monotony of which is rarely
relieved by buildings or trees.
With this gloomy outlook to
landward and with the bright
visions which lie to seaward,
the little plot remains at all
seasons of the year, wrapped in
its own solitude. No garlands
are strewn here and the perfume
of lowers never sweetens the
air. The buried dead in this
ground have no mourning visitors
like those who repose in the
humblest cemeteries elsewhere.
Even the grave-digger avoids the
place when his work is not
required there, and the
body-snatchers hold aloof from
the spot in wholesome awe. In
stormy weather the loud surf
dashes against the sea wall and
drives salt spray over the
neglected mounds, while the
misshapen trees creak and
tremble before the blast, In
storm the roar and in calm the
ripple of the moving waters near
at hand are heard there.
Not far from the burying-ground
the reporter found an
intelligent young colored man at
work repairing a row-boat. He
said he had passed the greater
part of his life in this part of
Staten Island. "They've been
burying people that die on ships
in that ground ever since I can
remember," he remarked. "A while
ago there was a lot of talk
among the neighbors here of
having that burying-ground taken
away from there. Folks mostly
don't like it. I suppose it's
because the people they bury
here from the ships died of
yellow fever and such as that.
But there ain't been no talk of
taking it away of late, and I
guess it will be kept where it
is. Every now and then the folks
get a fit for having the bones
carted off, and then the first
thing you know the thing is all
dropped. I don't see as that
graveyard can hurt us around
here much. The graves is ready
dug when the bodies come ashore,
and they just throw them in and
cover them right up, so the
disease don't get any chance to
start here. That yard ain't half
so much a nuisance as that
factory along the shore there
where the dirty smoke comes out
and makes the air so it ain't
fit to breathe. I've never been
in that factory myself, but I've
got white friends who tell me
about it. Lots of gentlemen come
down around here in the Summer
to fish. The fishing is good,
but the swamps just turn out the
mosquitoes. There's millions of
them, and they're always hungry.
We sometimes wish we was them
yeller fever chaps that's got a
foot or so of ground 'twist them
and the mosquitoes. It's
frightful cold down here in
Winter, specially when the wind
blows from on the water. I once
see them bury a poor chap in
that ground. They just hurried
his coffin off off a tug-boat
and dumped it into the grave.
They didn't have no prayers, but
they just covered him up with
dirt and left. Some Summers they
only bury six or seven there,
but other Summers they do a good
deal more planting in that
ground. Sometimes when it comes
Winter the friends of some one
get out a permit and have the
body removed."
A number of years ago, when the
plot was first selected for this
purpose, a hospital building was
built on it and a small dock ran
out from the sea wall. From the
first the people of the
neighborhood have objected to
this burying-ground. Some 15
years ago they became greatly
incensed against the quarantine
authorities. One evening a
prominent citizen of the
vicinity was seen stealing away
from the enclosure. In a few
moments the hospital building
was in flames. The neighbors
were called out to extinguish
the fire. Some of these people
were known to have thrown oil
instead of water on the flames.
The building and the dock were
both burned, and the prominent
citizen mentioned was arrested.
The authorities feared that he
would be acquitted if the trial
was held before a Staten Island
jury, and they arranged for his
being tried in some other
county. He was being taken down
to the ferry-boat when he was
brought back on a writ of habeas
corpus. He finally escaped
punishment. Neither the hospital
building nor the dock have been
rebuilt.
Every year just before the
Legislature meets the subject of
the removal of this
burying-ground is agitated, but
after a while the matter is
dropped only to be taken up the
following year. Once a tug-boat
Captain took a body from the
West-bank Hospital to Seguine
Point and was burying it when a
party of neighbors approached
with guns and dogs and he was
obliged to take to a tree. He
finally escaped without injury,
but he refused to bury another
body there. Sometimes the good
people threaten to dig up the
graves and remove the bones, but
this mood leaves them before any
steps have been taken. Many of
the more conservative citizens
have no strong objections to
this burying-ground, as there is
little danger of disease being
spread from the bodies buried
there. In 1875 the Legislature
passed a bill in which it was
provided that the Quarantine
Commissioners should remove
these remains from Seguine
Point.
They were directed to sell at
auction the grounds, and with
the proceeds to purchase other
grounds to which the remains
which were then at Seguine Point
should be removed. But the bill
explicitly stated that these new
grounds should not be within-in
the Counties of Kings, Queens,
or Suffolk. As it would not do
to procure a site in the County
of New York, and as the citizens
of New Jersey might object to
having placed on their soil a
cemetery for the interment of
persons who had died of
contagious diseases within the
limits of another State, the
Commissioners had no alternative
but to remove the graves to some
other portion of Richmond
County. But the people of any
other vicinity would have
objected to a cemetery of that
nature as strenuously as did
those residing near Seguine
Point. It would certainly have
been criminal to have thrown the
infected bodies into the Bay.
Had the citizens of Richmond
County obtained an injunction
against the landing within its
limits of such bodies, the
Commissioners would have been
forced to erect a cremation
furnace somewhere near the
West-bank Hospital. But the
latter were quite willing to let
bad enough alone, and since the
passage of the bill in 1875 they
have made no particular efforts
toward carrying into effect the
clause which provided for the
removal of the old Quarantine
burying-ground.